2021 UDATE ON JIS SCREWDRIVERS
It's been a dozen or so years since I appear to have introduced the topic of JIS screwdrivers on BurgmanUSA. This resulted in a fair amount of comments, some disagreements, and, I think, a lively discussion. In any event, I thought I'd update the availability of these screwdrivers, along with a few additional comments.
A Brief Recap:
In 2008 I started this thread:
I just thought I'd share this with anyone interested, given the increased use of reservoir-cover add-ons and since I couldn't find anything in BUSA about it. The screws holding the brake-reservoir covers in place are Japanese Industrial Standard (JIS) slotted, similar to but not Phillips...
www.burgmanusa.com
I noted that plain ol' Phillips screwdrivers were not optimum for removing some of the screws on the Big Burgers, particularly the brake reservoir cover screws. This likely applies to other Burgman models, and lots of other bikes (especially Japanese-made ones).
In addition to my initial post, if you go to post #14 (
Proper Screwdriver for Brake Reservoir Covers), you'll read that long-time BUSA member Kory (
@Colchicine) verified my findings, after I rode down from NY to VA with a few screwdrivers among my belongings.
The State of JIS and Screwdrivers Since Then:
It appears that JIS has been essentially superseded by the more universal DIN 5260-ph standard (and perhaps some other related DIN standards). You can do your own research on the history of JIS and evolving DIN standards, if you're interested in that topic. The point is that you may or may not see this type of screwdriver labeled as "JIS," or DIN-such-and-such, or even "crosspoint," but they are all very similar, and they are all NOT "Phillips" screwdrivers.
And I've acquired a few more such screwdrivers since 2008:
[Note: disregard, for the moment, the two rightmost, non-JIS, screwdrivers.]
In the non-Phillips realm,
the three on the left are my go-to screwdrivers, ever since I bought them in 2018. I got them from a company called
Go Fast Innovations:
Note that those prices are in Canadian loonies, and the last time I ordered a set (for a friend, in 2020) the shipping was included in the price.
These are very beefy and well-made screwdrivers, with nice grippy yet somewhat flexible, um, grips. And you can pound on the metal non-tip end with a hammer, I suppose, although I've never done that.
These appear to be the same set available on (the US version of) Amazon, either with or without additional bits:
(The brand is listed on Amazon as "RIFTWILD," but my searching indicates that that's a powersports distributor, not a manufacturer. Who knows.)
Moving rightward past the three GoFast screwdrivers,
the next four are the original Hozan screwdrivers, the ones I was using way back then.
The next two screwdrivers are the updated version of the Hozans. Actually, I have two more of these, but they're on the Burger now, in my tool ditty bag, under the seat, and I didn't feel like getting them out.
Here's that set on Amazon:
Amazon.com: Hozan JIS-4 JIS Screwdriver Set (New 3rd. Gen) (Japan Import): Home Improvement
www.amazon.com
Their angular plastic handles provide a better grip than the ones on the earlier set. They're somewhat light-weight and correspondingly light-duty, but they’re also certainly cheap enough. These are the ones I'd recommend your buying, if you're just starting off in the world of JIS, or still need convincing that not all screws that look like Phillips head are actually Phillips screws.
Those tiny "0" and "00" sizes, by the way, are pretty rare on bikes. They do come in handy, though, when working with electronics, such as laptops and cameras.
Next is a packet of bits from JDV Products/Vessel Tools (
Home). I rarely resort to using these bits, although I suppose they're good for tight spaces, where you might want to put one in a small 1/4" ratchet, for instance. (I save putting bits in an electric drill for special purposes, such as deck screws with special-purpose, perhaps "double-square," heads. I never put a Phillips or JIS bit in power equipment; you're just looking for trouble.)
There's a story with these Vessel bits.
Since its inception, the massive motorcycle site webBikeWorld was owned and managed by a sole proprietor, Rick Korchak. Before Rick sold that site to some corporation in 2017, I wrote about a dozen articles for wBW, as what you might call in the publishing biz a "stringer," and came to know Rick.
webBikeWorld published a few articles that involved JIS screwdrivers:
No, I didn't write any of those articles, but I did add some thoughts in their comments sections. In conjunction with that last article, Rick sent me those Vessel bits (and a few others) to check out, experiment with, etc. You'll find most of my report back to him in the comment labeled
Follow-up From “B.P.” (January 2016): (currently the second one down, among the comments).
In terms of the utility of each bit, particularly in terms of fitting reservoir-cover screws (in that case, on a Victory bagger), some worked better than others. But, as I said earlier here, I hardly ever use the bits; I've included them here for completeness, is all.
Speaking of bits and completeness, if you're really into using bits,
Motion Pro, a purveyor of assorted special-purpose motorcycle tools, also sells bits. It labels these "JIS Cross Point," so it covers several bases at once, in sizes 1, 2, and 3:
Motion Pro - High quality cables, tools and controls for motorcycles, ATVs, snowmobiles and personal watercraft.
www.motionpro.com
These are available on Amazon, too, (at higher prices, although it may work out better if you get free shipping from Amazon). Just do a search of that site for
Motion Pro JIS and you'll find them.
Finally, we come to the two screwdrivers on the far right.
These are actual Phillips screwdrivers, made by Klein. I bought these in 2008, at the suggestion of
@speed, who opined in that original thread that what I really needed were some high-quality Phillips screwdrivers.
It turns out that these are in fact very high quality. I recommend these screwdrivers, and they have become my go-to screwdrivers for actual Phillips heads. [
Update to this update: but see the comments by
@ibuzzard in post #22 below, regarding what he states to be the decline in Klein quality in recent years. This has apparently occurred since I bought mine in 2008.]
Just yesterday, I was doing some lock work at my daughter's house. And, not knowing what standards I would be dealing with, here's what I brought along in a bag of tools:
This is the same procedure I'd use if, say, a kitchen cabinet hinge is loose. That is, if it's not a slotted screwhead, go out to my toolbox and come back with #1 and #2 versions of Phillips and JIS screwdrivers, and see what fits best.
Here are the Kleins on Amazon (although, as I noted back then, I bought mine at Home Depot -- I don't know whether they still stock them):
As I say, the Kleins are very good screwdrivers. It was around that time that I learned just how crappy the tips on my Craftsman Phillips screwdrivers were. I still use the big #3 and #4 Craftsman Phillips -- and those are 40-something-years-old, so I give them credit for longevity -- for those very rare occasions that I encounter a Phillips head that large. Here's my screwdriver tray (minus, as I say, a few that are kept on bikes):
And I think that's it, for my screwdriver recommendations.
If it were up to me, we wouldn't be dealing with this at all. My riding buddy's Beemer uses Torx-head screws and bolts almost exclusively, and that's the direction I'd go if I were in charge of such things. The only decision you have to make on that bike is finding the proper size; once that's done, there is none of that potential for head-buggering, the kind you're trying to avoid when dealing with Phillips or even, to a lesser extent, JIS.
Happy motoring.